Kelleys Island

Situated in Lake Erie and part of Erie County, this small island community recorded just 7 active listings at a median home price of $189,000, with buyers paying roughly $255 per square foot for homes averaging 1,585 square feet. With a permanent population of only 198 residents, the local housing market is notably tight and low in turnover. The owner-occupied rate of 93.5% reflects a strong preference for long-term ownership rather than rental activity, which is somewhat unusual given the island's appeal as a seasonal destination. Median household income sits at $91,875, suggesting that residents who do plant roots here are financially stable relative to many rural Ohio communities. Kelleys Island Local School District serves the area's school-age children. Prospective buyers should expect limited inventory and should monitor new listings closely, as properties in this geographically constrained market do not appear frequently and competition for available homes can move quickly.

Market description generated from current MLS and U.S. Census data.