New Middletown

Tucked into Mahoning County with a population of just 1,632, New Middletown is a small, tightly held residential community where homeownership is the norm — 74.5% of households are owner-occupied. The current market reflects limited inventory, with only 9 active listings available, which tends to support stable pricing in a town this size. The median home price sits at $279,500, with properties averaging 1,844 square feet and a price per square foot of $233. That sizing and price point positions the market as relatively accessible compared to broader regional benchmarks, particularly given a median household income of $50,833. Buyers with children typically look to the Springfield Local School District in Mahoning County, which serves the area. The low turnover and constrained supply suggest that well-priced homes here move without extended time on market, making it a competitive environment despite the modest number of active properties at any given time.

Market description generated from current MLS and U.S. Census data.